Potterphiles like myself know two basic truths: First, the seven books penned by the brilliant J.K. Rowling are a tremendous read. And, second, the movies are a sad, sad substitute for the books.
The latest case in point? The recently released “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince,” which our family saw Wednesday afternoon.
Sidebar: Normally, we only go to the theater before noon on weekends, the better to take advantage of the $5 pricing. However, the Mister and the #2 son were going to be at a disc golf tournament all weekend, so we made an exception for Harry. We were too anxious to wait!
We all liked the movie, especially all the humor, but for the #1 son and I, we couldn’t help but lament what was left out from the book. The filmmakers concentrated too much on the romantic relationships in the movie at the expense of action and important events. I understand that the movie has to appeal to the millions who haven’t read the book, especially teenagers, but it was so ridiculous that there was hardly any information about the half-blood prince. Snape admitted to Harry that he, in fact, was the prince, but it was almost a throwaway line. There was no storyline about how Snape got to be called the HBP.
We did find out a bit about Voldemort’s past as Tom Riddle, who was creepily played by Hero Fiennes-Tiffin.
Sidebar: Does that “Fiennes” sound familiar? Young Hero is the nephew of Ralph Fiennes, who plays the adult Voldermort!
The filmmakers really grabbed the Golden Snitch when they originally cast Daniel Radcliffe (Harry), Rupert Grint (Ron), and Emma Watson (Hermoine). The three have grown into their roles and have become fine actors. In fact, everyone in the cast makes this movie so watchable and enjoyable.
The one actor who was especially sensational in “HP and the HBP” was Tom Felton, who plays Draco. Even though I have a hard time believing that Voldemort would trust a student to kill a gifted wizard like Dumbledore, Draco’s inner turmoil about having to complete such an onerous task was palpable. You could just tell his heart wasn’t in it.
Despite not being at Draco’s hand, Dumbledore’s death was just heartbreaking. Although I knew it was going to happen, it still made me cry. Such a sad moment for Harry in a short lifetime filled with sad moments.
As disappointing as it was for the movie not to include Dumbledore’s funeral, I did really like the wand tribute by the Hogwarts’ students and staff that erased the dark mark from the sky. Tons of emotion during that scene. The end of the movie set up the final films very nicely. Look for me to be intrigued by movies #7 and #8 but also to be disappointed. I have no doubt that Potterphile truth #2 will hold true: Those movies will be a sad, sad substitute for the book version of “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.”
But I already can’t wait to see them!