![SURVIVOR: TOCANTINS Survivor: Tocantins—the final four](https://susansternberg.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/final-four.jpg?w=500)
Survivor: Tocantins—the final four
Last night’s “Survivor: Tocantins” finale proved that nice guys can finish first! The ultimate nice guy, James “J.T.” Thomas Jr., complete with a disarming Alabama drawl, was only the second unanimous winner (Earl Coles of “Survivor: Fiji” was the first over the infamous Dreamz).
Full disclosure: Watching “Survivor” is one of our favorite family activities. We’ve seen every season of the show together (the first season in reruns on cable), and we’ve always enjoyed guessing who will be voted out, as well as who will win. We’re just weird that way.
This was one of the few times that it was obvious who was going to win. The 24-year-old J.T. played the complete game: He won plenty of immunity challenges, including the final three; he was a hard worker; he was extremely likeable; and he had that awesome southern drawl! Plus he was cute to boot. He went up against Stephen Fishbach, his best friend in the game, in the final. We thought Stephen might get a vote or two, but J.T. turned out to be more popular (he also won the $100,000 Sprint favorite player award). In the game of “Survivor,” just like in high school, popularity counts.
![SURVIVOR: TOCANTINS Tamara "Taj" Johnson-George](https://susansternberg.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/taj.jpg?w=500)
Tamara "Taj" Johnson-George
Even though we really liked both J.T. and Stephen, we hated that they dumped Taj in favor of taking Erinn Lobdell to the final immunity challenge. Taj was part of their Jalapao threesome that turned the game on its ear post-merge. The guys’ reason for opting for Erinn over Taj was totally illogical: They thought Taj might have a better chance to win the immunity challenge. Hardly! Taj hadn’t come close to winning a challenge all season, while Erinn almost beat J.T. in the previous one. We would’ve respected the guys much more if they had stayed loyal to Taj, who was more deserving of the final three than Erinn.
![SURVIVOR: TOCANTINS J.T., Erinn, and Stephen take the fallen comrades walk.](https://susansternberg.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/jt-erinn-stephen.jpg?w=500)
J.T., Erinn, and Stephen take the fallen comrades walk.
That being said, we still have to give props to Erinn, who proved to be the game-changer for the outnumbered Jalapao tribe post-merge. She wisely defected from Timbira where she was sixth and last to Jalapao where she figured she’d at least finish fourth. Ending up third overall was great for her. But it still should’ve been Taj in the final three!
![Survivor: Tocantins - The Brazilian Highlands Coach: One of the most-colorful players to ever play "Survivor"](https://susansternberg.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/coach.jpg?w=500)
Coach: One of the most-colorful players to ever play "Survivor"
Dumb move time
First rule of the post-merge in “Survivor”: If you have a tribal advantage, vote out the other tribe before you pick off your own players. Timbira, which had a power struggle between Brendan and Coach, didn’t get along enough to remember that they had the upper hand, 6 to 3. For the final two to be both from the outnumbered Jalapao tribe? Unbelievable! At the reunion show, Stephen said Coach unwittingly helped them by providing inside information that he had gotten from Tyson to J.T., enabling them to anticipate Timbira’s moves.
Ah, Benjamin Wade, aka Coach! He was a trip!! Always spouting philosophy about warriors and being held captive by natives. Definitely one of the most-colorful players in “Survivor” history. That being said, our family was so glad when he was finally voted out; he wasn’t one of our faves.
![SURVIVOR: TOCANTINS Stephen keeps busy with the final immunity challenge.](https://susansternberg.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/final-challenge.jpg?w=500)
Stephen keeps busy with the final immunity challenge.
Random “Survivor” snippets
• Loved the final two immunity challenges! It’s always tougher on the production team to come up with interesting challenges when they’re in a landlocked area. The penultimate contest looked like a tarantula; it was so cool! The final one was a-maze-ing . . . it was the ball and chute maze pictured above.
• What about that bromance between host Jeff Probst and Eddie George, Taj’s husband? Holy cow, any opportunity to spend time with the former pro football player. It was a veritable lovefest! No offense to Eddie, but I’d rather they had spent more time with the “Survivor” cast.
• Loved, loved, LOVED that J.T. is a mama’s boy! His mom had pestered her cattle-ranching son for three years to apply. He also would quote his mom from time to time while on the show. Pretty cute.
• The show is promised at least two more seasons; in the fall is “Survivor: Samoa.” We still love it and plan to watch it, no matter what. There’s just something about how unpredictable this social experiment in adverse conditions becomes after 39 days with former strangers that captures our fancy.
• A shout-out to Ethan Zohn, the winner of “Survivor: Africa,” who has been diagnosed with cancer. Here’s hoping he remains a survivor.